Timothy Cardinal Dolan Recounts Conclave Experience to Sold-Out Crowd

Image of Cardinal Dolan speaking at a podium on stage, engaging the audience with his message.
Timothy Cardinal Dolan shared his experience at the Conclave with a sold-out crowd at Fairfield University’s Regina A. Quick Center for the Arts.
By Kiersten Bjork

On Thursday, Sept. 4, 2025, His Eminence Timothy Cardinal Dolan joined the Fairfield University community for “Reflections on the Conclave and the New American Pope: Leo XIV.”

Presented at the Regina A. Quick Center for the Arts by the Office of Mission and Ministry, the evening kicked off with a welcome by Phil Klay, associate professor of English in the John Charles Meditz College of Arts and Sciences, a prayer led by Rev. Paul Rourke, S.J., vice president for Mission and Ministry, and an introduction of Cardinal Dolan by Fairfield University President Mark R. Nemec, PhD.

Cardinal Dolan was greeted with energetic applause from the packed house—the event was sold out well in advance and had accumulated a lengthy wait list.

With humor and a deep understanding of the historical context that brought us to this moment in the life of the Church, His Eminence recounted the road that led to the election of Robert Prevost, the first American to ever ascend to the papacy.

"The Cardinal put his unsurpassed talent as a natural entertainer in service of the Church’s supernatural mission," said Fr. Rourke. "The audience oscillated between being on the edge of their seats and rolling in the aisles with laughter. We couldn’t have asked for more.”

Cardinal Dolan highlighted the pedagogical styles of the three most recent popes, John Paul II, Benedict XVI, and Francis—the first Jesuit pope, describing them as the soul, mind, and heart of the Church, respectively. In the Cardinal’s eyes, Pope Leo XIV is a “successor, not a continuator” of the works of his predecessors.

His Eminence described the new pope as temperate, which he considers an attractive quality that may have supported his election, and expressed that Leo XIV has a calmness to him that was appealing as the cardinal electors sought the next leader of the Church.

Cardinal Dolan told the audience that while the finer details of the Papal Conclave remain secret, the daily rhythm included deep prayer, reflection, and many rounds of voting, which he likened to a silent retreat.

His Eminence closed his remarks with the parting thought, “grace builds on nature,” and received a lengthy standing ovation from the audience before he was joined on stage by Klay and Fr. Rourke for a Q&A session during which the Cardinal was asked to elaborate on how Pope Leo XIV’s “Americanness” may have affected his election.

Cardinal Dolan explained that the former Cardinal Robert Prevost “wasn’t thought of as an American,” but perhaps instead displayed the qualities that many people associate with Americans—good with money and practical. Then, with a smile, the cardinal also pointed out the new pope’s distinctly American, enthusiastic wave when he first greeted the crowds waiting outside—a clear difference from the more grandfatherly, reserved gestures of prior popes.

“The Cardinal managed the difficult feat of being insightful, substantive, and revelatory without violating the secrets of the Conclave,” said Fr. Rourke. “He placed the election of Leo XIV within the context of his three predecessors and made a compelling case that the Holy Father combines the best elements of all three."

Related Stories