Beyond the Court

By Sara Colabella EdD’26
Smiling Nicolette Loeffler ’27 with long brown hair poses against a plain gray studio backdrop, wearing a black Fairfield Tennis Nike top; the portrait feels warm and upbeat.
Nicolette Loeffler ’27

For Nicolette Loeffler ’27, tennis was more than a sport. It was her identity, her escape, and the place where she felt most like herself.

A Division I tennis player at Fairfield University, Loeffler had spent years working toward the opportunity to compete at the collegiate level. But a health challenge forced her away from the court and prompted her to reconsider who she was beyond the sport.

After a year and a half of severe abdominal pain, difficulty eating, and weight loss, Loeffler was diagnosed with Median Arcuate Ligament Syndrome (MALS), which led to open abdominal surgery in September. Losing tennis during recovery brought an unexpected struggle.

“Tennis had always been my escape, and suddenly I couldn’t turn to it anymore,” she said. “I went from being someone who was constantly active and pushing myself to someone who had to slow down and accept that my body couldn’t do what it used to.”

She felt disconnected and questioned who she was without competition. The experience helped her recognize that her value extended beyond athletic performance.

“Being an athlete is part of who I am, but it isn’t all that I am,” she said.

That realization became the foundation for ARMOR OFF, an initiative Loeffler created to encourage openness, connection, and support among student-athletes.

Taking Off the Armor

On a black background, a bold silver “ARMOR OFF” logo pairs block and brush lettering with the tagline “MORE THAN A GAME FACE,” creating a rugged, sporty tone.

Loeffler recognized that athletes often feel pressure to appear strong, even when they are struggling. Those expectations, she believes, can make it difficult to acknowledge when help is needed.

“For a long time, I felt like I had to keep telling people I was fine, even when I wasn’t,” she said.

The name ARMOR OFF reflects the image athletes can feel compelled to maintain in uniform. Beneath that image are people navigating fear, insecurity, illness, injury, and challenges others may never see.

“ARMOR OFF is about creating a space where athletes don’t feel like they have to wear that armor all the time,” she said.

Through athlete spotlights, personal stories, and behind-the-scenes content, Loeffler hopes to connect athletes across Fairfield’s athletic programs and highlight the people behind the uniforms. She is also connecting with Fairfield Athletics to explore mental health awareness events and opportunities to bring teams together.

Finding Support at Fairfield

A psychology major in the John Charles Meditz College of Arts and Sciences, Loeffler has been interested in the connections among mental health, identity, and well-being. Her health challenges made classroom concepts such as resilience and social support especially meaningful.

Her head tennis coach, Jeff Bricker, helped her feel ready to return to campus. After spending significant time away, Loeffler worried about feeling disconnected from her team. Bricker listened and reminded her that she still had a place on the team, whether or not she was competing.

“His support made a huge difference in giving me the confidence to return to Fairfield,” she said. “It also helped me realize just how meaningful it can be when someone takes the time to make an athlete feel seen and valued beyond their performance.”

She has also connected with people involved in student-athlete mental health initiatives at Fairfield, including Stags Care, and hopes to keep developing ARMOR OFF as a community where athletes can share their experiences and support one another.

Loeffler believes mental health should be part of everyday conversations in athletics, not just designated awareness events. Her message to athletes who feel they must keep saying they are fine is simple: “You can be strong and still need help. Those things can exist together.”

After graduation, she hopes to pursue a master’s degree in psychology focused on athlete mental health and sport psychology. She also plans to expand ARMOR OFF to other universities through athlete stories, events, and collaborations.

“Tennis has given me so much,” she said. “But one of the most important things this journey has taught me is that my purpose can extend far beyond the court.”

Related Stories